The owner's ruling of 2026-10-30 (d7): a chamfer that reaches or runs
past a rim builds, everywhere, as SMLib's cliff overflow builds a convex
blend: on its faces' continuations, then cut by what the cliff cuts
away. The earlier rule refused a chamfer whose leg runs off its face.
SolidCraft has no such refusal of its own; SMLib refuses these, so the
cases fail on SMLib 985faaee and are listed with its reasons (traced in
gdb at SmFilletErrorInfo::NoteError):
- the sloped basin's single front edge past its rim (1 mm rim 2 and 3,
0.5 mm rim 4): CloseRemovalRegion, "a cliff overflow's fillet boundary
lies on the surfaces of two faces": the sheet's boundary along the end
wall's top edge line from the edge's vertex to the top's contact
(x = 20, y from -1 to 1, z = 30) lies on the top's plane and the end
wall's both.
- the equal-slope basin's rim loop 2 and the 5 mm pocket's rim 5.5:
CloseRemovalRegion, "a cliff overflow's fillet boundary closes on one
face" (every edge of the loop blended).
- the sloped basin's front and right edges 2: status 1001,
SmFilletNx2Corner, CalcFilletIntSideFace.
- the cylinder's rim 2 across the top and 25 down its 20 mm wall: status
1001, SmFilletNx1ClosedCorner cannot compute its geometry.
Expectations, each from a closed form or an exact quadrature:
- chamfer_wider_than_sloped_basin_rim_is_refused becomes
chamfer_wider_than_sloped_basin_rim_builds, ignored until SMLib builds
it: the triangle clipped to y >= 0, times 30 + z (shoelace):
73.450475, 142.112912, 184.526613; the rig's 1080-chamfer-sloped-
basin-*-past-the-rim cases: V = 144459.882858, 144391.220421,
144082.140054.
- blend_corner's a_rim_loop_chamfer_running_off_its_rim_is_refused
becomes ..._builds, ignored likewise: sliced at depth t the mitred loop
takes the pocket's rectangle grown by w(t) = d (1 - t / delta) on each
side, clipped to y >= 0, less the rectangle, Simpson exact on each
quadratic piece: 375.673069, V = 139957.660264 (the rig's
1080-chamfer-equal-slope-basin-1-mm-rim-loop-2 too).
- 5835-chamfer-sloped-basin-1-mm-rim-2-two-edges: the same slicing with
the front and right sides grown, 161.279149, V = 144372.054184.
- every-chamfer-pocket-rim-5-5-past-the-floor: 50 d^2 + (4/3) d^3 at
5.5, the groove 0.5 deep round the floor included, V = 19265.666667,
15 faces.
- 2893-chamfer-two-distances-past-the-bottom: the frustum r 8 to 9.6
over 20, pi 20 (64 + 76.8 + 92.16) / 3 = 4879.102831, 3 faces.
Each drops "-refused" from its id (the 5.5 pocket's says past the floor).
The same slicing reproduces the existing 5835-...-4-mm-rim-2-2-edges
(176.006388), equal-slope loop 0.5 (24.455545) and half-width
(5.426545) values.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>