A primitive cut skips the sheets kernel::apart (exact bounds grown by the record tolerance)
finds clear of its tool; the bend check leaves the clear case to kernel::boolean, which answers
it from the same exact boxes with no intersection work. The mesh-box helpers are gone, and their
four lines leave xtask/mesh-decisions.txt (172 sites left).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01DtL5M41G8Nua7HvuFPZkmJ
Each round runs whole to its section square to its edge at its setback (the owner's rule, at
least 1.5 r, scaled to the least at which the G1 fill is certified convex), and the hole is the
setback split: one patch per round and the triangle in three quadrilaterals, 15 faces, G1.
Outside the box the sections span the body is the three strips', so its volume is theirs within
that box's. A later r3 round at the mitred corner makes the body all three at once make
(7928.142563938, 15 faces), as the engine and the model-cache tests have it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01DtL5M41G8Nua7HvuFPZkmJ
SMLib's setback corner takes a G1 fill only once certified convex, and refuses a setback too
short for that as SMLIB_ERR_NO_ROOM with SMLIB_FIT_SETBACK_AT_LEAST, the smallest setback that
builds. The kernel reads it (solidcraft-smlib binds smlib_blend_fit_size) and names it; the
Fillet dialog says it in plain words. Other room refusals keep their words. The r5 box corner
set back 5.5 is refused naming 5.962, which builds.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01DtL5M41G8Nua7HvuFPZkmJ
The round's cylinder keeps the frame it was made on when it is turned (SMLib's SwapUV no longer
re-derives it): its origin sits at x = −20 on the same axis line, (x, 2, 8) along x, radius 2.
Same cylinder; one number in the record moves.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01DtL5M41G8Nua7HvuFPZkmJ
SMLib's Ball corner is always the rational patch exactly on the sphere (owner ruling, blend
design §23), so the corner counts as an 'other' face beside the three cylinders and six planes.
The removed volume still checks the corner against r³ − πr³/6.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01DtL5M41G8Nua7HvuFPZkmJ
removed_by_balls integrates, in each plane square to a right-angled edge, the corner the union
of the balls leaves (by rays from the edge, the least entry over the balls), cut to the body's
section. The law with a corner through a middle point is its own test, listed as failing.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
On the round's rails the order-2 section takes off what the ball's circle does: (1 - pi/4) s^2 at a
square corner, first moment 0.0474559669443 s^3 (w = -0.5252123889). The kernel and engine tests
and the curvature rig cases take their volumes from it by their own methods; the pipe on the plate
from its own wedge (70.52878 degrees, w = -0.8544103493). The G2 corner patch's seam test is listed
until the corner step.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A loop that runs out along a chain of edges and straight back (a meridian from a sphere's pole
stopping short of the other, out and back) encloses no (u, v) area, yet on a closed surface it
bounds all of it less a cut of none. The reader only read such a face when the slit already ran
pole to pole (and moved the sphere's frame onto it only then), so the 2 mm ball whose meridian
stops at 2.5 rad was refused for its empty loop.
The slit is now made the face's seams, so its loop bounds the surface's whole domain: on a
sphere, a revolution whose profile ends on its axis, or a spline closed round u that collapses
at both ends, the slit's meridian is run on to both poles, out and back (a sphere's frame put
on the slit first, whichever two points it joins); on a torus, the circle the slit lies along is
closed and the other circle through its start is the second seam. The seams on a sphere are its
own meridians (angle 0 on the equator), so their pcurves are exact lines on its form.
Tests: non_antipodal_seam_sphere_imports_as_a_whole_ball passes (its known-failing line goes);
seam_only_torus_imports_as_a_whole_ring adds a torus bounded by a slit along its tube.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A loop that uses each of its edges once each way (a whole torus within its tube and ring seams)
is the same set of uses run backwards, so it says nothing of the face's side. One written
clockwise in (u, v) turned the face over, against its same_sense: the torus came in inside out
with a warning. Such a loop is now reversed and the face keeps its side.
Test: seam_only_torus_imports_as_a_whole_ring, both orders of the two seams, volume 2π²Rr².
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A projected spline edge of several Bezier spans came into the sketch as one
curve per span (#1508), so a G2 round's bottom edge was 16 curves and a path
naming the corner named one span of it (#3604). The kernel now reads such an
edge (a spline, or an elliptical arc of several spans) as the one clamped
B-spline it is over the edge's interval, its knots and weights its own, and
the sketch takes it as one control spline whose ends sit on the edge's
vertices. Planar regions still read edges span by span. The 3604 case builds
with its original path and leaves KNOWN_FAILING.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A face tool cut with that face's surface alone, so a face of a surface body made of spans joined
tangent (a fit-point spline extruded, #3830) cut nothing where its span ends inside the body.
Split Body by a face of a surface body now takes the faces joined to it tangentially (the exact
check Extend uses, within the one angle for smooth) and slices with them as they are, through
SMLib's slice by a sheet (smlib_split_body_by_sheet, tangency-labs/smlib 7a01f1b), its sides those
of the picked face. A sheet that only nicks the body cuts nothing, as before; a lone face, or a
face of a solid, still cuts with its surface extended.
3830 comes off the booleans list. Its answer counted the two halves of the cup and not the surface
that cut it, which stays as a body of its own (4879 removes its surface for that reason): three
bodies, the volume unchanged.
Needs SMLib 7a01f1b pinned (SMLIB_REV, prebuilt; its SMLIB_ABI_VERSION 6, which crates/smlib now expects) to link.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A surface body of more than one face (a fit-point spline's spans extruded, #3830) was refused.
Each face with a picked edge is now extended alone by SMLib's extension of its surface, and the
faces are sewn back together, each the face it was. A side that lengthens onto a face meeting it
tangent takes that face along, past its edge continuing the picked one; across a crease the
neighbour grows only when its edge is picked too, otherwise the extension is refused. Faces whose
lengthened sides no longer meet are refused. Up to a target keeps the pieces every grown face
lies in.
3830's extensions now build; its split still fails (the tool point picks one span, and a face
tool cuts with that face's surface alone), so it stays on the list with that reason.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The owner's rule of 2026-10-30: a round running past a rim of its faces
into open air builds; one whose section would remove material through to
a hollow behind its edge (a slit into the hollow, a cut through the part)
is refused as too large, so the fillet names the largest radius that fits.
Decided exactly in the section of a straight convex edge between planar
faces: the round's centre is at depth r below both planes, and it opens
where its arc uncovers a boundary point strictly inside the wedge with no
material beyond it toward the centre (the body's exact point
classification). Looked at: straight edges parallel to the round's (a
hollow's corner), cylinders about parallel axes (a rounded corner), and a
picked concave parallel edge's own round, which fills the corner.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
chamfer_wider_than_sloped_basin_rim_builds and a_rim_loop_chamfer_running_off_its_rim_builds
waited for SMLib to build the cliff overflow (CloseRemovalRegion refused it,
SM_FILERR_NO_ROOM). The pinned SMLib builds it (eddf0ede4, bba9914b6): both pass on aarch64
Linux and are no longer ignored.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
SMLib's point classification at the body's own tolerance, on the exact faces and edges, in
place of a mesh at a chord of 2e-3 of the body's size (about 0.4 mm on a 200 mm part). A point
within the tolerance of a face, edge or vertex is OnBoundary, never decided by a ray. A mesh
body's triangles are its exact shape: on them within the record's tolerance, else by ray
crossings. The kernel's own probes move to it; Body::contains goes once its last callers have.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NvoxKQ2rEZvcXNQnhE3Sgs
SMLib (smlib-batch-4-rulings 0e83cca, SMLIB_ABI_VERSION 5) rounds the edges whose rounds overflow
their faces first and then what is left of the others; smlib_blend_dropping says which picks'
edges the overflow removed whole. The smlib crate binds it (Brep::blend_dropping), the kernel
returns those picks (fillet_removing), and a fillet notes them as its warning: "the edge at
(0, 0, 10) was removed by the larger round, so it is not rounded" (a 50 x 50 x 20 block, R21 on
its bottom front edge with the front left upright: the block is R21's alone, in closed form).
Ruling d8: [21, 5, 5] on a 20 cube builds as R21 alone (6107.529370); the test is no longer
ignored. R25 with R2 at a corner (blend_corner) builds the same way, R25's alone in closed form,
where it was refused. The rig's 1080 notched block outline at R8 builds now and comes off the
known-failing list.
Needs SMLIB_REV at that SMLib once it is pushed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
With SMLib's smooth limit at half a degree (422e6f1) the 1 degree crease rounds R2 and R20
(the test is no longer ignored), and with a cusp's chamfer the ball of radius d (d231547) the
The 0.5 one stays, for its own cause (the chamfer face left apart from the body). Two corner
cases the same SMLib (replay/1.0.1 and those commits) builds come off too.
Needs SMLIB_REV at that SMLib once it is pushed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
R21 on a 20 mm cube's edge builds (6107.529370, closed form, to 2e-12). With R5 on the
corner's other edges the R21 takes the faces they lie on, so the body is R21's alone; SMLib
fails that blend (status 1001, fillet error 4, Unable to Trim Rail Curve) and the test is
ignored until it builds. It replaces the refusal test that expected TooLarge.
Ruling d8 (2026-10-30).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The blend's tangent angle is the shaded view's half degree (smooth_edges::ANGLE), one value
for smooth. A constant round lies r (sec(d/2) - 1) inside the crease it replaces (about
r d^2/8); below the edge's tolerance it changes nothing and is refused before SMLib (which
answered SM_ERR_INVALID_INPUT), naming the smallest radius that rounds,
tolerance / (sec(d/2) - 1). d is the least turn along the edge
(tangent_edge::least_angle_along, at tangent_all_along's stations).
Ruling d3 (2026-10-30). The block's tolerance is 2e-5 mm, not 0.1 um: at 1 deg the smallest
radius is 0.526 mm, so R2 and R20 reach SMLib, which still calls an edge within 2 deg smooth
(SmEdge::GetBlendEdgeuse); that test is ignored until SMLib uses 0.5 deg.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
three_rounds_at_a_corner bounded the patch's extra cut at 3 mm³ beyond the strips, a figure
with no derivation; SMLib's all-at-once body at radii 2, 3, 4 takes 3.099 (V 7878.579574
against strips 7881.678). That body is the strips' outside the block its patch lies in: its
rounds are the strips' cylinders ending at a's section y = rc, b's x = 20 − rc and c's rails
where they meet a's and b's (the patch's four corners, now asserted), so the patch takes at
most what the strips leave in that block (11.86 at 2/2/3, 32.69 at 2/3/4). The lower bound is
that block; the upper one, at most the strips' volume, stays.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The rounds that made a body are over the body its history is over: a new history (an
operation carrying a step's result back to its own operands) leaves the record out, so a
later round never reads one history against another body. Body::rounds gives the record and
Body::with_rounds_of takes one back, checked (edges of the body before them, a fillet's
radii, the body's history over that body), for a saved model to keep it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The owner's ruling of 2026-10-30: a later fillet on an edge at a vertex where earlier
rounds already meet in a mitre makes the corner rounding all of them at once makes, one
smooth patch, the mitre gone. A body made by constant-radius rounds keeps what they were
made on and which edges they rounded at which radius; a later round reaching such a corner
blends the earlier rounds' edges (from the earliest of those meeting there on) with the new
edges in one SMLib blend of the body before them. The result's history is put over the body
the later round was given: an earlier round's face is that face trimmed anew (its name
kept), the corner patch and the new rounds are the later fillet's. A picked mitre seam has
no round of its own: it is refused unless a new edge of its radius meets it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Since tangency-labs/smlib#67 an extruded profile's arcs on one circle sweep one
full-turn wall face, made from all of them (Profile 4, 5 and 6 here), where it
was a face per arc. The geometric check of the record finds a face over several
segments by its triangles' centres and vertices on them; the revolved arcs keep
a face each.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
An imported solid's faces were mapped to the file's only when SMLib's export numbered them as the
record did (native.rs, numbering). The export is in canonical order, which can list edges
otherwise: the two periodic-knot tubes of #1374 came back with their seam and rim edges listed
[2, 0, 1, 5, 3, 4], so the sheet, a valid B-rep, was refused as "SMLib renumbered the solid's
faces". The export's order says where SMLib's own face and edge i went; put back in SMLib's
order it numbers them as the record does, and SMLib's i is the record's i (an import lists them in
the record's order). numbering now takes that too, checked the same way; an edge split into
pieces is no renumbering and stays unmapped.
The tube test asserts what it should: one surface body, not a mesh, its faces the file's two
faces in order, every face meshed, in under a minute, and the area exact: each face is the file's
quadratic circle (corner weights sqrt(2)/2 to 12 digits) moved straight along its axis, a
cylinder's side, so 2 * 2 pi r h, which SMLib's measure meets to 1e-6.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A solid SMLib refused came in as a surface body of its faces; where SMLib could not stitch those
either, the importer meshed them with SolidCraft's planner and kept the triangles as a mesh body
(step_in/parallel.rs, mesh_part). A build without SMLib showed it: every STEP part of the import
rig came in as a mesh of its faces. That fallback is gone: the solid is not imported, and its
warning names it and gives the kernel's reason ("solid 'Cube': not imported: ..."); a file whose
every solid is refused fails with the same words.
The import report tells a part the kernel refuses (Refused) from one the reader cannot read
(NotImported), and its summary says "N parts couldn't be made into solids and were not
imported" in place of the mesh sentence (en, ar, de, he, ja, ko, zh). STL, 3MF, OBJ and glTF
still come in as mesh bodies: that is what those files are.
The two-tube sheet of #1374 had come in only through that fallback: SMLib's export lists its
edges in another order, which the next commit maps. Until then its test asserts the refusal and
meshes the faces as read at the body's coarse display tolerance, the regression it guards.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Validation::EachStep checks every solid sweep, boolean and blend result
in SMLib as before; EachFeature leaves those checks to the end of the
feature and says a check was left; Off skips them. The evaluation installs
the mode around a feature (validating), as watch installs a watch; outside
it every step is checked as always, and the kernel's worker threads run
under the caller's mode.
Under EachFeature a body decoded from a step keeps that step's SMLib
result (for its own record only), and check_kept checks it as the step's
own check would have, then lets it go; any other kept body is checked as
SMLib imports its record. The record can pass where the result fails: a
fillet's surface of revolution whose polar curve SMLib's check refuses
(fillets/1080-fillet-sloped-basin-1-mm-rim-r0-5-4-edges) is rebuilt on
import, and its round meets a wall at 72 degrees; checking the record
alone kept that round.
The largest-size search of a blend checks every candidate as it is built,
whatever the mode: a candidate fits only as a body the check accepts.
Surface operations and stitching keep their checks.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The owner's ruling of 2026-10-30 (d7): a chamfer that reaches or runs
past a rim builds, everywhere, as SMLib's cliff overflow builds a convex
blend: on its faces' continuations, then cut by what the cliff cuts
away. The earlier rule refused a chamfer whose leg runs off its face.
SolidCraft has no such refusal of its own; SMLib refuses these, so the
cases fail on SMLib 985faaee and are listed with its reasons (traced in
gdb at SmFilletErrorInfo::NoteError):
- the sloped basin's single front edge past its rim (1 mm rim 2 and 3,
0.5 mm rim 4): CloseRemovalRegion, "a cliff overflow's fillet boundary
lies on the surfaces of two faces": the sheet's boundary along the end
wall's top edge line from the edge's vertex to the top's contact
(x = 20, y from -1 to 1, z = 30) lies on the top's plane and the end
wall's both.
- the equal-slope basin's rim loop 2 and the 5 mm pocket's rim 5.5:
CloseRemovalRegion, "a cliff overflow's fillet boundary closes on one
face" (every edge of the loop blended).
- the sloped basin's front and right edges 2: status 1001,
SmFilletNx2Corner, CalcFilletIntSideFace.
- the cylinder's rim 2 across the top and 25 down its 20 mm wall: status
1001, SmFilletNx1ClosedCorner cannot compute its geometry.
Expectations, each from a closed form or an exact quadrature:
- chamfer_wider_than_sloped_basin_rim_is_refused becomes
chamfer_wider_than_sloped_basin_rim_builds, ignored until SMLib builds
it: the triangle clipped to y >= 0, times 30 + z (shoelace):
73.450475, 142.112912, 184.526613; the rig's 1080-chamfer-sloped-
basin-*-past-the-rim cases: V = 144459.882858, 144391.220421,
144082.140054.
- blend_corner's a_rim_loop_chamfer_running_off_its_rim_is_refused
becomes ..._builds, ignored likewise: sliced at depth t the mitred loop
takes the pocket's rectangle grown by w(t) = d (1 - t / delta) on each
side, clipped to y >= 0, less the rectangle, Simpson exact on each
quadratic piece: 375.673069, V = 139957.660264 (the rig's
1080-chamfer-equal-slope-basin-1-mm-rim-loop-2 too).
- 5835-chamfer-sloped-basin-1-mm-rim-2-two-edges: the same slicing with
the front and right sides grown, 161.279149, V = 144372.054184.
- every-chamfer-pocket-rim-5-5-past-the-floor: 50 d^2 + (4/3) d^3 at
5.5, the groove 0.5 deep round the floor included, V = 19265.666667,
15 faces.
- 2893-chamfer-two-distances-past-the-bottom: the frustum r 8 to 9.6
over 20, pi 20 (64 + 76.8 + 92.16) / 3 = 4879.102831, 3 faces.
Each drops "-refused" from its id (the 5.5 pocket's says past the floor).
The same slicing reproduces the existing 5835-...-4-mm-rim-2-2-edges
(176.006388), equal-slope loop 0.5 (24.455545) and half-width
(5.426545) values.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The owner's ruling of 2026-10-30 (d7): a chamfer that reaches or runs
past a rim builds, everywhere. The earlier rule refused a full-width
chamfer, naming the largest size that fits. SolidCraft has no such
refusal of its own (a blend's TooLarge is SMLib's SMLIB_ERR_NO_ROOM,
and the doc layer only names the largest fit), and SMLib already builds
these, so only the expectations change, each from a closed form or an
exact quadrature:
- chamfer_wider_than_sloped_basin_rim_is_refused's full widths become
chamfer_as_wide_as_sloped_basin_rim_builds: the whole triangle,
d drop / 2 (60 - drop / 3), drop = 20 d / sqrt((20 - margin)^2 + 400)
(shoelace over the section, its length 30 + z between the sloped end
walls): 21.662379 (1 on 1 mm), 5.359321 (0.5 on 0.5 mm). The basin and
the removal move into sloped_basin and sloped_basin_rim_chamfer_removed.
- fillets/1080-chamfer-sloped-basin-{1,0-5}-mm-rim-as-wide-as-the-rim:
V = 144511.670954, 144261.307346.
- fillets/every-chamfer-pocket-rim-5-full-depth: 50 d^2 + (4/3) d^3 at
d = 5, V = 19583.333333, 11 faces (the walls used up).
- fillets/every-hole-top-rim-chamfer-10-full-depth: the triangle 10^2/2
revolved at rho = 5 + 10/3 (Pappus), V = 16000 - 3250 pi / 3 =
12596.607959, 7 faces.
- fillets/1113-chamfer-arc-top-edge-full-wall-height: the 9.5 case's
Int rho asin(21/rho) h(rho) drho at s = 10, by Gauss-Legendre in
u = asin(21/rho), 1303.400331, V = 8287.993768.
Each drops "-refused" from its id and its KNOWN_FAILING line goes: all
five pass on SMLib 985faaee.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A G2 corner patch's side is G2 to its round except near the face it ends
on, and SMLib holds each side as two edges. The smooth-join test judged
each edge alone, so the G2 half was hidden and the line stopped at the
vertex in the middle of the seam. Edges between the same faces that
continue each other at a shared vertex now share one verdict: smooth only
where every one of them is.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>